Prop 74 has me thinking in a lot of different ways. When I first read through the legislative analyst, I decided to vote YES on Prop 74. I am now going to walk you through the conversations that I’ve had this week.
My conservative Christian friends vote YES and more than likely all Republicans will. Don't get me wrong, though. Although I am Christian, I am not a Republican.
Prop 74 is going to change the probationary length from 2 years to 5 years. Only Indiana and Missouri are currently on a 5 year probationary period. After the 5 years (or 2 years as of now) then a teacher becomes tenured. Once a teacher is tenured, it is harder to fire that teacher. I wish I could talk to a teacher from one of those states!
The way I see it, if you're a good teacher prolonging your probationary period 3 more years shouldn't matter to you. Who cares if the principal observes you more? You should want the principal and superintendent coming into your class to see how well of a job you are doing. And besides, the kids are quieter when the principal's in the back of the room! Haha!
However, my colleagues have raised the question, "All other professions are able to be hired and feel secure about their job within at least one year. What other profession can you say has a worse off job security? It's just making it even harder for people to stay in this field. It's bad enough that new teachers get burnt out so easily with everything this No Child Left Behind Act has demanded." My take on this is, "Put a doctor's proposition on the ballet and I'd vote yes too." Was this prop really put on the ballot to punish teachers for speaking out against the governor’s poor record on education and criticizing him for breaking his promise to fully fund our schools?
Another concern my colleagues noted was how much it sucked during the two year probationary period where you can't really say anything or rock the boat because you didn't want to get a bad review. I, on the other hand, feel that I didn't really have a good feel for this job until this year - which just so happens to be my fifth year. So perhaps teachers shouldn't be able to have an easy say in things until they have been in the field a little bit longer. However, my first year was in third grade, and the other four years have been in second.
The big thing that almost turned my vote to NO is because this Prop gives the money hungry, power greedy district employees - and not to mention our governor who has no idea what he's talking about when it comes to education - the right to fire great teachers without a defined reason.
You see, the way a teacher gets a raise is by staying in the district and taking classes that offer units. Let's say I just get hired and start my salary at $38, 914. In my district my salary remains the same for the next 3 years - unless I take 15 units and then I move over to another bracket. For the sake of reasoning, I’m not going to take any units. In my district the first 3 years is at $38,914 and will increase from year 3 to year 4 to $39,101. Again in my district, years 4 and 5 remain the same. But after that fifth year, my salary will increase to $41,635. So let’s say that Prop 74 were to come into place. Let’s also say that my district wants to save money. Then, they can fire all of the teachers that are about to receive tenure and hire all new teachers again. By doing so, they will be saving $2,721 per new teacher that year. This is a great scheme for them; but what about my loyalty to this district and the job security that I need? I’m finally at my fifth year and have a handle of how this district and school runs things but they dump me just like that so that they can save money? That’s what I think is extremely unfair and where the problem is hidden in this proposition.
Prop 74 is also going to make it so that if a tenured teacher gets 2 bad reviews consecutively, than they can be fired. This is the part that I like about Prop 74. It's not like I see a lot of very bad teachers out there but often times there are the stagnant teachers that get so set in their ways that they are not willing to modify their teaching styles to better fit the needs of the students in their district. I also see teachers that are not written up for a lot of the things they do or don’t do that makes them a bad teacher.
A colleague of mine said that one of the reasons why a particular teacher won’t get written up could be because the principal doesn’t want to have it on their record when they are ready to move into a position at the district office. It is currently a long dismissal process for a permanent, or tenured, teacher. With Prop 74, the board would not have to go through the lengthy process and give more last chances for that “bad” teacher to play the game and keep their job.
Again, I think that this part of the proposition helps weed out the bad tenured teachers easier. And for those teachers that disagree I would have to say, “If you’re a good teacher, than you should have nothing to worry about.”
So there it is. Our governor is voting YES and he hasn’t been doing a good job with education thus far. The California Teachers Association and most of my colleagues are voting NO. They are pressuring me to “stick together” on this one. I, on the other hand, read the proposition and made my choice before consulting any one else and hearing other’s opinions. I am voting YES on Prop 74.